Impact assessment of transport infrastructure projects in northern vietnam. Before joining the world bank, he was the chief of advisors for the secretary of fiscal and social equity, and for the government of argentina and held other top positions in the chief of cabinet of ministries and the ministry of economy. Intervention community control study designed by amend and cdc. The ise is an information security vulnerability evaluation developed by the software engineering institutes networked systems survivability program. A cutoff rule to evaluate the impact of connecting roads on. Transport infrastructure impact evaluation cosme, silvia.
Impact assessment of transport infrastructure projects in northern vietnam jbic idcj ii table of contents executive summary 1. To address the problems of ease of access, maintenance, redundancy and. Includes an infrastructure inventory, which is a list of all infrastructure existing or available to and on the site, such as. Nrpa launched the gupc in 2015 with the primary purpose of improving environmental and social outcomes in underserved communities through promoting and advancing green stormwater infrastructure projects within parks and developing. It focuses on identifying vulnerabilities in an organizations computing infrastructure. Monitoring and evaluation of infrastructure projects has been recognized as an indispensable management function. Apr 21, 2017 critical infrastructure is defined in the usa patriot act p. This paper surveys the main lessons from impact evaluations of infrastructure projects, programs and policies relevant to policymakers. Common criteria for the assessment of critical infrastructures. Costbenefit analysis compares the monetary costs and benefits of a project. Explains how to select an evaluation design, taking into account what the results will be used for, what the evaluation questions are, which parts of the programme are actually evaluable, and which evaluation designs can be used. This guide, which would function as a manual, could serve the purposes of assisting. Steps in the impact evaluation of afdb financed rural.
But the evaluation departments of the various development agencies have been. Eight years letter, it was thought appropriate to look back for a comprehensive understanding of the achievements, limitations and way forward for the programme. March 2012 iob evaluation from infrastructure to sustainable impact. Impact evaluation of transport interventions asian development. Impact evaluation of urban water infrastructure upgrades in. Pdf a survey of impact evaluations of infrastructure. Paljp law and justice infrastructure impact evaluation. Many studies that deal with infrastructure criteria, however, use consequencebased criteria to connect the supply capacities of infrastructures with impact scenarios of potential damage ec 2008. Impact evaluations of irrigation projects in four asian countries. Impact of transport infrastructure investment on regional.
The evaluation used an innovative methodology that combined data analysis and extensive interviews with stakeholders. Provision of infrastructure that would provide the transport benefits while enabling urban renewal and promoting. Relative to the resources devoted to studying the effectiveness of interventions in health and education, those available from all sources for evaluation of criminal justice programs are meager. Impact evaluation of greengrey infrastructure interaction on built space integrity. Although the education community has identified numerous effective interventions for. Evaluating the exact magnitude and significance of the impact of a particular type of infrastructure on economic outcomes can be of interest for multilateral. Operationally critical threat, asset, and vulnerability. Infrastructure workforce and workplace the rand corporation is a nonprofit research. Impact evaluation of greengrey infrastructure interaction. Economic cooperation and developments development assistance committee oecd. A range of methods are available for counterfactual analysis of infrastructure interventions, as illustrated by the variety of papers in this volume.
Adequate funding is a prerequisite for sustaining a critical mass of timely and highquality impact evaluations distributed over the criminal justice programs of national and regional policy interest. Introduction 2 since the mid2000s, the interest in analytically robust evaluations of the impact of projects, programs or policies has exploded among development academics and field workers. In parallel to these trends, behavioral economics has increasingly attracted. Impact evaluation of urban water infrastructure upgrades in tanzania olga rostapshova, phd 1, danae roumis, msc 1, jeffrey alwang, phd 1,2, john feighery, phd 1,3 1 social impact, inc 2 virginia tech. Impact evaluation of urban water infrastructure upgrades.
Monitoring and evaluation also both serve accountability purposes. Keywordssocial impacts and variables, social impact assessment methods for road infrastructure projects, cost benefit analysis, analytic hierarchical processes introduction introduction of social impacts the means of impact assessment as per the comprehensive guide for social impact assessment 2006 centre. Office of strategic planning and development effectiveness. Impact of time savings and the use of time saved 82. Impact evaluation is, however, critical to the success of the infrastructure. Social impact is conducting a rigorous impact evaluation of the mcc tanzania water sector project wsp, to assess how improvements in urban water supply infrastructure affect health and human capital outcomes in dar es salaam and morogoro, tanzania. However, the assessment of impacts is not a straightforward task. Undertaking rigorous impact evaluations is particularly challenging in infrastructure projects, due to their long and unpredictable timelags between project completion and the manifestation of develop mental impacts and outcomes as stated in the banks standard resultsbased logframe. Organisation for economic cooperation and development development assistance committee, evaluation of development programmes. An infrastructure evaluation depends on the type of property, its location, assets and the potential site reuse options. Steps in the impact evaluation of afdb financed rural road. A survey of impact evaluations of infrastructure projects, programs and policies antonio estache 1 february 2010 revised march 2010 1.
It is a public good that enables the creation of a wide range of. Nonie is a network of networks for impact evaluation comprised of the organisation for. Forming a counterfactual is very difficult in many of these cases, and so the question is what one could think of doing. Aug 28, 2011 one of the interesting discussions i had this last week was with a world bank consultant trying to think about how to evaluate the impact of largescale infrastructure projects. Impact evaluation report 114 evaluating the impact of infrastructure development case study of the konkan railway in india. General guidance and existing evidence find, read and cite all the research you need. Choosing an impact evaluation method 187 determining which method to use for a given program 187 how a programs rules of operation can help choose an impact evaluation method 188 a comparison of impact evaluation methods 193 finding the smallest feasible unit of intervention 197 chapter 12. The importance of infrastructure development to highquality literacy instruction vol. In 2010 and 2011, we launched four evaluations to test. Selected programs for impact evaluation 69 table 6. Improving evaluation of anticrime programs is designed as a working guide for agencies and organizations responsible for program evaluation, for researchers who must design scientifically credible evaluations of government and privately sponsored programs, and for policy officials who are investing more and more in the concept of evidencebased. Monitoring tracks performance of projects, both in terms of costs and outputs, against their expected values. Infrastructure is an enormous untapped potential for the creation of productive employment. Impact evaluation is the main means for empirically testing what actually happens when interventions are implemented.
Impact of training and education on sanitation and hygiene 77 table 7. Impact evaluation population based doortodoor surveys at catchment areas around 18 primary schools in dar es salaam, tanzania secondary data unreliable sample size calculated for 33% reduction baseline and followup data collected from 2 populations. Impact evaluations for infrastructure projects, is undertaking. Guidelines for critical infrastructures resilience evaluation. Based on the results of these studies, to develop an evaluation framework, which includes. Request pdf impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions the focus on results in development agencies has led to increased focus on impact evaluation to demonstrate the effectiveness of. He worked with numerous latin american governments on issues on infrastructure and impact evaluation. Toolkit for monitoring and evaluation of agricultural water.
Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions request pdf. After a brief discussion of the motivation for the explosion of the demand for impact evaluations, it starts with some sometimes underestimated lessons for. Onsite infrastructure such as fire and life safety. A survey of infrastructure impact evaluations march 2010. The impact of private sector participation in infrastructure. Infrastructure protection is the ability to prevent or reduce the effect of an adverse event. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions 1st edition henr.
An evaluation study has been initiated in 2008 for addressing some of such issues. Impact of water supply and sanitation assistance on human welfare in rural pakistan ganesh rauniyar, aniceto orbeta, jr and guntur sugiyarto 62 6. Impact assessment of transport infrastructure projects in. Islamic republic of afghanistan ministry of economy. Introduction many third world countries have numerous projects in an attempt to improve their infrastructure and this improves the standard of living of its citizens. Transforming development through impact evaluation. The importance of infrastructure development to highquality. Guidelines for impact evaluation in education using experimental design rosangela bando. The spread in the continuous discovery of new threats that target cis, stress the importance of a whole rethinking around the concept of protection. When we think of infrastructure, we first think of roads, bridges, water supplies, and electrical grids, but infrastructure also takes less tangible forms, such as ideas, basic research, and the internet. All the impacts associated with a capital project are identified and, where possible, costs and benefits valued in monetary terms, so that the projects selected by government will provide the maximum net. Pdf impact evaluation report 114 evaluating the impact of. Impact evaluation makes a causal link between a project and a set of results. Green infrastructure design and implementation us epa.
Infrastructure projects are being realized because of their supposed positive impacts. The present impact evaluation study and the report on fist programme is the result of the. Strategies for evaluating the impact of big infrastructure. Project evaluation is a methodology for assessing the economic, social, environmental and financial impact of proposed capital projects. We first worked in collaboration with experts in the field6 to understand the relevance and limit of experimental techniques for the kind of activities our funds support. World bank group impact evaluations independent evaluation. Increasingly, evaluation processes are used that foster wider participation, allow dialogue, build consensus, and create buyin on recommendations. The green infrastructure evaluation framework is an offering of nrpas great urban parks campaign gupc. Considers different methods for evaluating impact using the principles of attribution. A study by john fernald makes progress on establishing causality by comparing the impact of infrastructure investment on industries that a priori should experience different benefits from.
Area types in order to design a generic cycling infrastructure evaluation framework the framework, the. Low impact development lid is an approach to stormwater management that emphasizes the use of smallscale, natural drainage features integrated throughout the. Understanding impact means understanding the context in which an intervention takes place. In this article, an impact evaluation scheme is proposed, capable of determining the.
Evaluation of law and justice infrastructure impact. Impact evaluation is a great complement to monitoring and costbenefit analysis. World bank group impact evaluations june 2012 relevance and effectiveness world bank group impact evaluations isbn 97818297176 sku 19717. Pdf a survey of impact evaluations of infrastructure projects. Ayele published impact assessment of road infrastructure. It is widely accepted that a theory based approach to impact evaluation, one that maps out the causal chain. Texas civil engineers give the states infrastructure a c grade on wednesday, the texas section of the american society of civil engineers asce released preliminary findings including grades from its 2021 texas infrastructure report card, the sections first report card since 2017. An impact evaluation of investment in infrastructure.
Pdf evaluating and monitoring the socioeconomic impact of. Directorate of economic evaluations and infrastructure sharing report economic impact evaluation of the targeting the ultrapoor project tup in bamyan province evaluated by ms. Paljp law and justice infrastructure impact evaluation final. Constraints, evaluation, monitoring, projects, successful, third world. The particular focus of this law and justice sector infrastructure impact evaluation ljsljs iie was to provide an understanding of how the investments in infrastructure have impacted access to law and justice services and how this has improved service delivery, especially as it is. An evaluation of the fiscal impact of allegheny county mental health court m. The focus on results in development agencies has led to increased focus on impact evaluation to demonstrate the effectiveness of development. Evaluation contributes to learning through both the process and the final product or evaluation report. Huge sums of money are put into this activity and it is important to get value for money. Impact evaluation in transport publications interamerican. Project monitoring and evaluation and performance of road projects according to harrison 2008, project monitoring and evaluation involves routine collection and analysis of information to track the progress of a project. International initiative on impact evaluation, 3ie email. Steps in the impact evaluation of afdb financed rural road projects. Understanding impact means understanding the context in which an intervention takes place and.
Pdf impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions. In the process, however, it also reveals some major research gaps of relevance to academics. In recognition of these facts, the development of africas infrastructure and economic integration are key components of the strategic direction being pursued by the bank. Impact evaluation of urban water infrastructure upgrades in tanzania olga rostapshova, phd1, danae roumis, msc1. Impact evaluation initiative and in 2009 the network nonie had published the guidance of impact evaluation5. A survey of impact evaluations of infrastructure projects. Pdf impact evaluation report 114 evaluating the impact. Infrastructure resilience is the ability to reduce the magnitude, impact, or duration of a disruption. Response patterns from baseline data collection for this impact evaluation suggested a need to better understand respondent comprehension and recall related to water supply, illness, shortage. As stated in the national infrastructure protection plan nipp nipp 20. The evaluation looked at 34 sites across 6 provinces, where australian funded infrastructure. The focus on results in development agencies has led to increased focus on impact evaluation to demonstrate the effectiveness of development programmes.
436 319 283 354 616 391 1242 1031 879 164 1348 778 792 352 1202 313 908 822 1161 1238 580 1309 898 424 970 596 358 873 1007 983 281 278 242 1440 143